The fresh new disclosure framework additionally the standard meaning of so it verse was perhaps not, yet not, with the question of relationships to help you non-Muslims. The fresh new traditional interpretation claims that the verse is found when a few polytheist men out of Quraish asked for the siblings to-be right back, Oum Kelthoum and Bint Aqabah, when they had transformed into Islam and you may migrated so you can Medina inside purchase to join the fresh new Muslim people.

It generalized suggestion isn’t necessarily correct and “strength” or the “weakness” of your own spiritual belief is not in the intercourse but as an alternative into strona istnieje man or woman’s identity and you may reputation

It is worthy of reminding your Prophet finalized during the time a binding agreement entitled Al-Hudaybya Treaty on the face-to-face group off Quraish to quit the fresh new combat for 10 years. It arrangement specified, among others, you to people Quraychit woman who would join the Prophet into the Medina without having any consent of the woman court teacher is going to be repaid to Mecca.

Oum Kelthoum, who was the only person to alter so you’re able to Islam within her family unit members, and you may who fled from one of the most extremely aggressive environments, begged new Prophet not to repatriate the girl to help you the lady group therefore while the to not ever getting started again on the unfair procedures.

The verse above mentioned was then shown to eliminate the fresh new extradition of females exactly who transformed into Islam and get away from new vengeance off their particular parents. Thus, the fresh new Prophet refused to send right back the newest exiled female into the foes, because the agreement try was able for men.

The explanation of your verse aforementioned signifies that it does maybe not handle at all the wedding to low-Muslims, however, was rather shown to meet up with some proper criteria regarding protecting women that transformed into Islam resistant to the usually of the household members and just who voluntarily asked for the fresh Prophet’s cover.

The newest contradiction that individuals focus on on these classical perceptions questions the newest simple fact that predicated on these scholars, Muslim women are not allowed to marry “disbelievers” along with Christian and you will Jewish males, when you are for the matter-of Muslim males, Christian and you may Jewish women are considered as believers. How do we envision, in identical Religious or Jewish neighborhood, one the male is disbelievers if you find yourself women of the same groups are believers?

About lack of any facts you to definitely justifies this new ban from the wedding out of Muslim people toward supporters out-of almost every other monotheistic religions, the fresh new contemporary students validate its perceptions by the “the sheer weakness” of Muslim ladies who might go astray within the “bad” dictate of the Christian otherwise Jewish husbands. But the Muslim son can take over his Christian or Jewish partner and you may protect their children’s and you may own believe.

New Qur’anic verse, tackling the marriage out-of Muslim men or women to help you believers of other religions, place specific legislation using a keen egalitarian code

Indeed, the newest dispute is not convincing because if the fresh new said verse forbids the wedding between a Muslim lady and you may a beneficial Religious or Jewish son because it’s unanimously interpreted today, therefore instance relationships is even taboo with the Muslim child. Nonetheless, based on individuals Qur’anic verses and the Islamic stability, Christians and Jews are considered unanimously given that believers belonging to religions revealed from the Allah regardless of the existing variations in terms of the fresh new dogma therefore the theological beliefs.

This is why, the research on the verse means that brand new Qur’an forbids the relationships away from one another Muslim individuals to polytheists.

But it is worth discussing one scholars consent unanimously with the prohibition of the relationships regarding a beneficial Muslim woman so you can a good Jewish otherwise Christian, whenever you are zero area of the Qur’an offers instance ban one justifies this discrimination.