The fresh disclosure context and general concept of that it verse was perhaps not, but not, associated with the geek2geek reddit matter of relationship to non-Muslims. The fresh new traditional interpretation claims this particular verse ended up being found whenever two polytheist men off Quraish required its sisters is back, Oum Kelthoum and Bint Aqabah, once they had transformed into Islam and you will moved so you can Medina within the order to become listed on the latest Muslim people.

This generalized suggestion is not always correct plus the “strength” or perhaps the “weakness” of your religious trust isn’t with the gender however, instead to your man or woman’s identity and character

It’s worth reminding the Prophet closed at that time a binding agreement named Al-Hudaybya Pact to your face-to-face group of Quraish to cease the latest battle to have 10 years. So it arrangement specified, yet others, one to any Quraychit woman who get in on the Prophet in the Medina with no permission off their legal teacher should be sent back in order to Mecca.

Oum Kelthoum, who was simply the only person to alter so you can Islam in her own family members, and you may exactly who escaped from a single of the most hostile environment, begged brand new Prophet not to ever repatriate the girl to help you her tribe therefore as not to be established once more on the unfair medication.

The newest verse previously mentioned was then found to avoid the extradition of women exactly who transformed into Islam and prevent the fresh vengeance out-of their respective parents. Thus, the newest Prophet would not posting straight back the exiled females on the foes, just like the agreement try was able for men.

The rationale of verse previously mentioned implies that it can not deal with at all the marriage to help you non-Muslims, but was as an alternative found to generally meet specific strategic conditions out of protecting ladies who transformed into Islam up against the have a tendency to of their relatives and who willingly wanted brand new Prophet’s protection.

The fresh new paradox that people highlight throughout these ancient interpretations concerns the brand new undeniable fact that according to such scholars, Muslim ladies are prohibited to help you wed “disbelievers” along with Religious and you may Jewish people, whenever you are towards case of Muslim men, Religious and you will Jewish women can be regarded as believers. How can we think, in identical Religious otherwise Jewish area, one the male is disbelievers while people of the same teams are believers?

In the lack of one proof one to justifies the new prohibition away from the wedding out-of Muslim ladies to your followers out-of most other monotheistic religions, the fresh modern students validate the thinking by “the latest absolute fatigue” off Muslim women that may go astray underneath the “bad” determine of their Christian or Jewish husbands. Nevertheless the Muslim kid can take over his Religious or Jewish wife and cover their children’s and you may individual believe.

The fresh Qur’anic verse, tackling the marriage regarding Muslim men or women in order to believers away from most other religions, place some laws and regulations using a keen egalitarian vocabulary

In fact, this new conflict isn’t convincing because if the newest said verse forbids the marriage between a great Muslim lady and you can good Religious or Jewish guy because it’s unanimously interpreted today, so instance relationships is additionally taboo to your Muslim son. Nonetheless, centered on individuals Qur’anic verses and also the Islamic ethics, Christians and you may Jews are thought unanimously due to the fact believers belonging to religions shown by Allah long lasting current differences in regards to the brand new dogma in addition to theological beliefs.

Thus, the research in the verse signifies that the latest Qur’an forbids the newest relationship out-of both Muslim individuals to polytheists.

But it is worthy of bringing-up that scholars concur unanimously towards the prohibition of relationship away from a great Muslim woman so you can an excellent Jewish or Religious, if you are zero an element of the Qur’an offers up such prohibition you to warrants so it discrimination.